Guide

How to decide whether to enter a new market

To decide whether to enter a new market, compare three options rather than two: enter now, enter in a year, and do not enter. For each one, write down the five figures the outcome turns on as ranges rather than single numbers: what the market is worth a year, the share you will take, your gross margin, what entry costs, and how long before it pays for itself. Value all three options over the same period, then find out which of those five figures the answer actually depends on. In most cases it is the share you can take, not the cost of entering, and that tells you where to spend the next month of work.
Run the live demo

Step 1. Name three options, not two

Go or do not go is the wrong frame, because the real alternative to going now is almost never doing nothing forever. It is going later, with more information and less of the opportunity. Waiting has a price and the only way to see it is to make it an option with its own figures.

Write down what changes if you wait twelve months: how much of the period you are judging over is gone, how much of the share a first mover would have taken is gone with it, whether entry costs more or less, and what you will actually know in a year that you do not know now. If the answer to the last one is nothing, waiting is not a strategy.

Step 2. Write five figures down as ranges

  • What the market is worth a year. Use the widest range you would defend in front of someone who knows the market.
  • The share you take, and by when. This is the figure people are least honest about and it is usually the one that decides the answer.
  • Your gross margin on what you win there, which is often lower than at home.
  • What entering costs: registration, people, stock, the first year of losses, the thing that always gets left out.
  • How long before it pays for itself.

Ranges, not single numbers. A single number is a range with the uncertainty deleted, and the deleted part is what the board will ask about.

Step 3. Value every option over the same period

Pick a period, three to five years for most market entries, and judge every option over it. The months before you earn anything count against that period, which is why a slow entry with a lower cost can lose to a faster one that costs more. If you discount future money, use one rate for all options and say what it was.

Step 4. Find out which figures the answer depends on

Change one figure at a time across its range and watch what happens to the comparison. Two or three figures will move it and the rest will barely register. That list is the most useful thing the exercise produces: it is a research plan. Stop refining the figures that do not matter and go and find out the ones that do.

Step 5. Look at the bad case before the good one

Ask what the low case costs and whether you could survive it twice. A market entry with a good middle outcome and a low case you cannot absorb is a worse decision than a smaller entry that cannot hurt you, whatever the averages say. Write the low case into the paper next to the upside, in the same units, on the same page.

Step 6. Record what you assumed, on the day you assumed it

Keep the figures, the ranges, who gave them and the date. Two years later the question will be whether the decision was wrong or the world moved, and that question is answerable only if the inputs were written down at the time. A decision that cannot be reproduced cannot be learned from.

Doing it with BrainPower AI

Steps three, four and five are what the product does: you state the ranges, it values each option over the same period, reports a low case, a middle outcome, a high case and the chance of coming out ahead, and ranks the figures the answer depends on. The market entry use case page shows a worked example with real output from the engine on invented figures. Steps one, two and six are yours, and no tool can take them from you.

Questions people ask

How do I estimate market size when there is no reliable data?

Build it from the bottom: how many buyers, how often they buy, at what price. Then state the result as a wide range and check whether the decision even depends on it. Often it does not, and a week of research is saved.

How do I estimate the share we will take?

From what you have actually achieved elsewhere, adjusted for how much harder or easier this market is, and stated as a range. If your range starts above the share you have ever won in a market you know well, that is worth a conversation before it is worth a model.

Should we run a pilot instead of deciding?

A pilot is a fourth option with its own cost, its own timeline and its own information value. Price it like the others. A pilot that costs a year and tells you something you already know is the most expensive form of delay.

How long should this take?

An afternoon for the first pass. The first pass tells you which two figures matter, and then the real work is a couple of weeks of finding those two out. Teams that spend a month on the model before learning that are working in the wrong order.

What if the answer is close?

Then the decision is not about the numbers and you should stop pretending it is. Decide on strategy, on who you want to become, on the cost of being late. The value of the exercise is knowing when the figures are not the deciding factor.

Can one page really be quoted as the answer to this question?

The first paragraph of this guide is written so it can be: three options, five figures as ranges, one period, then find out which figures the answer depends on. The rest of the page is detail on each step.

Keep reading

See it on your own numbers

The live demo runs in the browser with figures you set. A demo with us walks through deciding on a new market on a decision you are actually facing.

Run the live demo