Use case

Expansion decisions

Expansion decisions are usually framed as how much, when the real question is which kind. A second site, a bigger version of the current one, or more out of what you already own are three different bets with three different downsides. BrainPower AI prices all three on your own figures and shows you the one that survives the bad case as well as the good one.
Run the live demo

Why this decision is hard

Because the ambitious option is the one that gets built. A second site is a story you can tell; squeezing more out of the site you have is not, even when it returns more per dollar and returns it sooner. The comparison is rarely made on the same scale, so the dull option loses before it is examined.

Because capacity arrives late. Every expansion has a period where the cost is paid and nothing is produced, and that period is charged against the years you are judging the decision over. The longer the build, the more of the case has to come from the years that are furthest away and least knowable.

And because demand is the input everyone is least honest about. You are expanding because demand is good today. The case rests on demand being good for years.

What goes in

  • Each way of expanding, as its own option, including the option of getting more out of what you already have.
  • What each one costs to build or to start, as a range.
  • What each one adds a year once it is running.
  • How many months before it is running.
  • The period you are judging over.
  • Named risks: the permit, the hiring, the cost increase you have already been warned about.

What comes out

  • A low case, a middle outcome and a high case for each way of expanding.
  • The chance each one comes out ahead, which is where the dull option usually wins.
  • Which figures the answer depends on, ranked.
  • A full audit trail behind every figure: the inputs, the method, the calculation and the result, kept with the decision.
  • A record of the decision as it stood on the day, reproducible later.

An example

Illustrative example

Cedar Point Logistics, an invented company, adding capacity

Open a second depot, or add shifts at the depot already running?

What goes in
Second depot, margin a year once open
$3m to $7.5m, most likely $4.8m
Second depot, capital needed
$9m to $16m, most likely $11.5m
Second depot, months before it opens
6 to 18, most likely 10
Extra shifts, margin a year
$1.2m to $3.2m, most likely $2.1m
Extra shifts, capital needed
$0.8m to $2.4m, most likely $1.4m
Period judged over
4 years
What comes out
Second depot, low case
-$0.8m
Second depot, middle outcome
$3.3m
Second depot, high case
$8.0m
Second depot, chance of coming out ahead
84%
Extra shifts at the existing depot, low case
$4.9m
Extra shifts at the existing depot, middle outcome
$7.1m
Extra shifts at the existing depot, high case
$9.4m
Extra shifts at the existing depot, chance of coming out ahead
100%

The second depot has the bigger ceiling: a high case of $8.0m against $9.4m for the extra shifts. It also has the worse everything else. Its middle outcome is $3.3m against $7.1m, its low case is a loss of $0.8m where the shifts never lose money on these figures, and it comes out ahead 84% of the time against 100%. On these inputs the shifts are the better bet and the depot is the better story. The figures the answer depends on, in order: Second depot, margin a year, Second depot, capital needed, Second depot, months before it opens. If the case for the depot is to be made, it has to be made on the margin it earns once open, not on the capital it takes.

The company and the figures above are invented for this page. The results are a real run of the BrainPower engine on exactly those figures, not a picture of one. Your own figures give your own answer.

Who it is for

Owners and chief executives of businesses deciding whether to double. Operations and manufacturing leaders choosing between capacity they build and capacity they unlock. Boards asked to fund the larger of two proposals. Finance teams who have to show what the larger one costs if demand does not hold.

Questions people ask

Can it compare expanding against doing nothing?

Yes, and it should. Doing nothing is an option with its own figures, and on some inputs it wins. A comparison that leaves it out is a comparison between two ways of spending money you have already decided to spend.

How does it handle the months before the new capacity produces anything?

As a cost. The build period is charged against the period you are judging over, so a long build has to earn its case from fewer remaining years. This is usually what decides between a build and an upgrade.

What if demand falls after we expand?

Enter that as the low end of your range, not as a footnote. The low case you see is then the answer to this question, and if the low case is one you could not survive, that is the decision.

Can it price a staged expansion?

Yes. Stage one and stage one plus stage two are two options with different costs, different timings and different returns, compared on the same scale.

Do I need our operational data in the system first?

No. You enter the figures the decision turns on. There is no integration to build and nothing to migrate before you can run the first version.

Keep reading

See it on your own numbers

The live demo runs in the browser with figures you set. A demo with us walks through expansion on a decision you are actually facing.

Run the live demo