Use case

Investment risk analysis

Most investment cases describe the upside precisely and the downside in adjectives. BrainPower AI reports both in the same units: what the position returns in the good case, in the middle case and in the bad case, how often it loses money, and how that compares with the duller thing you could do with the same money instead.
Run the live demo

Why this decision is hard

Because the downside is the part nobody models. The deck has an exit multiple, a sensitivity table around it, and a page headed Risks that is a list of words. A reader cannot tell from that whether a bad outcome costs a fifth of the money or all of it.

Because the alternative is usually missing. An investment that returns a solid multiple is not obviously good if the same money lent at a known rate returns nearly as much with a fraction of the spread. Until both are on the page in the same units, the comparison is not being made.

And because a probability stated in a meeting is forgotten by the next one. If someone says there is a one in ten chance the buyer walks, that number should be in the model and visible in the result, not in the minutes.

What goes in

  • What you are putting in, and when.
  • What you expect to get out, as a range: an exit value, a multiple, or a stream of cash.
  • Cash paid out along the way, if any.
  • The alternative use of the same money, as its own option.
  • Events that either happen or do not, with the chance you would actually defend: a default, a buyer walking, a license refused.
  • The period you are judging over.

What comes out

  • The low case, the middle outcome and the high case for the position and for the alternative.
  • The chance of coming out ahead, and so the chance of not.
  • Which figures the answer depends on, ranked.
  • A full audit trail behind every figure: the inputs, the method, the calculation and the result, kept with the decision.
  • A record of what was assumed on the day, so a later review can see the case as it was, not as it is remembered.

An example

Illustrative example

Meridian Grid Services, an invented company, as an investment

Take a minority stake for $18m, or lend the same $18m for five years?

What goes in
Stake price
$18m
What the stake is worth on exit, as a multiple
0.4 times to 2.8 times, most likely 1.1 times
Cash paid out over the five years
$0 to $4.5m, most likely $1.8m
If lending instead, interest a year
8.5%
Chance the borrower fails to repay
8%
Share of the loan recovered if it fails
60%
Period judged over
5 years
What comes out
Take the stake, low case
-$1.2m
Take the stake, middle outcome
$9.1m
Take the stake, high case
$23.2m
Take the stake, chance of coming out ahead
87%
Lend the money instead, low case
$7.7m
Lend the money instead, middle outcome
$7.7m
Lend the money instead, high case
$7.7m
Lend the money instead, chance of coming out ahead
92%

The stake has the better middle outcome, $9.1m against $7.7m for the loan, and a high case of $23.2m. It also has a low case of -$1.2m, so one time in ten it returns less than nothing, and it comes out ahead 87% of the time against 92% for the loan. Read the loan carefully: its low case, its middle and its high case are all $7.7m, because a loan either performs or it does not. The 8 percent chance of the borrower failing does not show up in the low case, because it is rarer than one in ten and the low case reports the worst one in ten. When it does happen the loan loses $7.2m, which is 40 percent of the money. That is the comparison in one line: the stake pays more and can lose a little, the loan pays less and can lose a lot, rarely. The figures the answer depends on, in order: Exit value as a multiple of the price, Cash paid out over five years, Borrower fails to repay.

The company and the figures above are invented for this page. The results are a real run of the BrainPower engine on exactly those figures, not a picture of one. Your own figures give your own answer.

Who it is for

Investors and family offices sizing a position. Investment committees that have to minute a reason. Chief financial officers judging an investment against paying down debt or buying back stock. Advisors who would rather show a client the downside than be asked about it later.

Questions people ask

Does it value a company?

No. It computes what your own valuation assumptions imply for the outcome of the decision, across the range you are willing to state. If you want a single valuation number produced for you, this is the wrong tool.

How do I enter a risk that either happens or does not?

As an event with a stated chance, such as an 8 percent chance a borrower fails. It then shows up in the result rather than in a footnote, and you can see how much of the answer it is responsible for.

Can it compare an investment against doing nothing with the money?

Yes, and the alternative is treated as a full option with its own figures and its own risks, not as a hurdle rate. On the example on this page the alternative loses on the middle outcome and wins on certainty.

Is the output a recommendation?

No. It is a computation of your inputs. The product does not know your appetite for a bad year, and it does not pretend to: it reports the spread and the odds and leaves the decision where it belongs.

Can a result be reopened after the fact?

Yes. The same figures give the same answer, and the audit trail keeps what was entered and how the result was reached, so a post mortem can separate a bad decision from bad luck.

Keep reading

See it on your own numbers

The live demo runs in the browser with figures you set. A demo with us walks through investment risk on a decision you are actually facing.

Run the live demo